November 21, 2026

00:49:32

Q&A: Do Lutherans Believe in a Nudge from the Spirit? How Does Christianity Give Hope and Meaning? More

Hosted by

Bryan Wolfmueller
Q&A: Do Lutherans Believe in a Nudge from the Spirit? How Does Christianity Give Hope and Meaning? More
Theology Q&A
Q&A: Do Lutherans Believe in a Nudge from the Spirit? How Does Christianity Give Hope and Meaning? More

Nov 21 2026 | 00:49:32

/

Show Notes

Pastors Bryan Wolfmueller and Andrew Packer answer your theological and Biblical questions. In this episode they take up the question:

  • Is Santa killing your child's trust in the Gospel?
  • How does Christianity actually give hope and meaning to present life?
  • Do Lutherans believe in "a nudge from the Holy Spirit?"
  • Can our bodies heal themselves?
  • What is the proper place of humor in the Christian life?

Submit your questions here: http://www.wolfmueller.co/contact.

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Speaker A: Hey, YouTube theologians. Pastor Brian Wolfmother here together with Pastor Andrew Packer, Pastor of well look, Pastor Packer, I heard a rumor about you and that is that you've already gotten a wiffle ball bat tattooed on your back. True. [00:00:18] Speaker B: I got on my shoulder actually, like right here. [00:00:21] Speaker A: We were in Puerto Rico together this week. [00:00:24] Speaker B: It says we're number one and the. The one is the whiffle. It's [00:00:28] Speaker A: a heart I love with a wiffle ball bat in the middle of it. We were in Puerto Rico this, this weekend, which was great, visiting the missionaries down there and including one of the events was a men's retreat with a wiffle ball warm up game and you won the warm up. But we never got to the real thing actually, so we don't know who won. Pastor packers team or [00:00:52] Speaker B: we may never know. [00:00:55] Speaker A: We're answering your theology questions, Wolfmother. Co contact is where you can send those questions. What do you got, Pastor Packer? [00:01:03] Speaker B: Got a great one. As we get closer to December and we saw those Christmas trees in Puerto Rico, so [00:01:08] Speaker A: man, they are crazy about Christmas trees in Puerto Rico. [00:01:13] Speaker B: Yeah, they're already ready for Christmas. Even that concert we stumbled upon, the they were singing about Christmas is Coming. It was kind of an Advent concert, but they didn't call it that. Anyway, so this is. Is Santa killing your child's trust in the gospel? Is that. Is that a provocative enough title? [00:01:32] Speaker A: Yeah, let's see what it says. [00:01:35] Speaker B: All right. After the birth of our first child, it has occurred to my wife and I that we will still need to decide if we want to tell her about Santa Claus. Us. I believe that we should not lie to our child about anything. But I'm also sensitive to the arguments of C.S. lewis. Myth made fat. Could the joy Santa brings Christmas morning be a small taste of the joy Christ has in store for us? I'm worried that if we simply. If we imply Santa is real by leaving packages from Santa or eating cookies left out for him, and our child later comes to find out Santa is not real, perhaps our child will wonder if what we have told her of the Bible is also a lie meant to make our life orderly, enjoyable. In addition to this, we live our life knowing we are forgiven on account of Christ's death and resurrection. But could our child also live her life in fear of Santa's naughty list? This view of Santa through C.S. lewis's lens does not point to Christ for us, but instead a religion of the law as you have put it in your terrific resource, Christian Basics. We have talked to our Wonderful LCMS pastor about this and have had a great discussion. But I'm sure we are not the only ones who have ever struggled with this. Perhaps this discussion, although slightly humorous, could edify the wider church. What have you done with your own children? All right, so Santa. [00:02:43] Speaker A: This is great. [00:02:43] Speaker B: Tell us what to do about Santa. [00:02:45] Speaker A: Everyone ready for being upset one way or another? Can I tell you this? Great. One of the most wise things I ever heard. This is the context. It was Dr. Klein. Well, I had a vicar some years ago, years and years and years ago, maybe 15 years ago. And, and he was convinced that if you acted like there was a Santa Claus, then your children wouldn't believe in the resurrection. He was just 100% sure that finding out that Santa Claus isn't. Sorry. Warning. We're gonna. Spoiler alert. Finding out that Santa Claus isn't real was gonna. [00:03:22] Speaker B: Sorry, kids. [00:03:23] Speaker A: Was gonna destroy the kids faith in the resurrection as well. And so we argued about it for a couple of days and then we were sitting at lunch with Dr. Kleinek, who was visiting, and I said, why don't you ask Dr. Kleinig? And that resulted in the most amazing conversation in which Dr. Kleinig finally was so exasperated at the end of it, looked at the vicar and said, vicar, sometimes the devil loves to use our being right. And that's where that line came from. The devil loves to use our being right. [00:03:59] Speaker B: It's very true. [00:04:00] Speaker A: So, so I, look, I guess there's. You play with children, you know, it's. And this is. Santa Claus is a playing thing. And like I, you know, when I pretend that I'm a monster, I'm. Or I pretend like I'm a wolf and I'm going to eat the kids, you know, legs or toes or something like that. Or when I, you know, when we, there's just this playfulness that we engage the children with. And I think Santa Claus is one of those playfulness things that is just, it's just in some ways part of childhood you don't have to do it, but it's, I think that there's a, that there are things that are not real and things that are real and we, you know, teach those things to the children. I think this is just kind of how it goes with, with, with raising kids. So again, I don't think you, you have to do it, but I don't think you have to say that you, that you, that you can't do it. So I don't know. Again, it's like with our own kids, there was a couple of years where there was gifts coming down from Santa Claus. But I don't think that they were ever fooled, especially when, like, Santa Claus was bringing a present to our youngest kid, which was actually a present that he gave to our older kid, but had been in the attic for a couple years. And then the kids were like, wait a minute, Santa's. Santa's re. Gifting. What's going on there? So I'm not sure that I think that we probably could use a little more playfulness, a little more whimsy, a little more toying around with the kids than we do. There's a danger that we become so serious that, you know, that the children lose that childhood that I think not only we talk about, but I think the Bible talks about it too, that kind of innocence where in some ways, like GTH Chesterton says everything is magic. And I think Chesterton would say that the kids actually have a more right understanding of things when they see everything as magic than we do when we see everything as natural. [00:06:23] Speaker B: Oh, I have a lot of Chesterton quotes lined up here for this. I looked it up really fast because he talks a lot about Santa Claus. He actually says as he grew, he believed more in Santa, not less being part of it is this childlike joy and wonder with the season. So here's a couple. This one's just kind of funny. Personally, of course, I believe in Santa Claus, but it's a season of forgiveness, and I will forgive others for not doing so. He also says, or is a child to be forbidden all forms of fancy, or in other words, forbidden to be a child. And I think that's part of. If you read Chesterton on this, part of the joy and wonder of Christmas is. Includes things like Santa Claus. And it can be done in such a way. I think it can be done in such a way that perhaps, you know, you overdo like the, like bribing your children to be good, right? Like, don't be naughty or Santa Claus is going to give you whatever bad gifts, are not going to give you good gifts or whatever. But Chesterton's focus was always on the joy that Santa brings to children, right? Like it's this joy and generosity connecting it back to St Nicholas, of course, who you labeled yourself as and put me as the. The evil demon. But [00:07:32] Speaker A: what it's AI it automatically adds, reads what's going on. [00:07:38] Speaker B: Read our facial expressions. Knew it. [00:07:43] Speaker A: You know, it is there. Is that creepy. He knows when you are sleeping. He. It's like, what kind of weird surveillance kind of operation are you running over there. It's like Santa Claus, some sort of communist spy or whatever. [00:07:56] Speaker B: Well, I would encourage everyone to look into, like, the history of, like, even some of the stuff we have on Santa today is relatively recent, historically speaking, from, like, even the red suit, right. Comes from Coca Cola ads, like, all of these things. But kind of the joy and fun of that's always been there. And like you said, kids. Kids pretend and they exploit, you know, and they have fun with that. So I don't see any reason why you have to think, like, if I pretend with my children, they'll never believe the gospel. Kids figure out pretty fast as they grow up the difference between pretend and real. Right? Like, they grow up and think that. And I think only maybe if you do it in a really terrible way, are your children going to doubt you on both. You know, like, they're gonna be like, santa wasn't real. That means Jesus isn't real. That I just don't. I don't see as a problem. We're struggling with. And most of our. With most of our children, like, there's far deeper issues that are going on with our kids than, like, they're having fun with Santa Claus for a few years and then they grow out of it. Right? I mean, like Chesterton says, can we not allow them to be children? And I think that's pretty messed up if we think, like, I am duty bound, my conscience is bound that I can't pretend with my children because they'll think I'm lying to them about other stuff. Now, I do think this is my controversial take on this. I'm all for Santa. I think the Santa stuff is fun. Elf on the shelf, I really do not. Like, I kind of despise that for so many reasons. I think it's dumb, but I know people love it. If you like it, fine. You know [00:09:29] Speaker A: what? We [00:09:29] Speaker B: want nothing to do [00:09:30] Speaker A: with it. I invented this thing, and then I just have never had the chance to produce it. Is to do. Instead of the Elf on the Shelf is that you do a nativity scene where each day a new character appears and somewhere in the house. So then like, like there's a sheep and it shows up somewhere, and you gotta go and find the sheep, and then you gotta go find the wise man and you gotta find all the characters and bring them to the nativity scene. And each one of them has a little scroll with a. With a prophecy. So you have. You could do it all through the season of Advent or whatever. So you got it. So it's A. It's a nativity game where you're. Where each day a new piece of the nativity scene is arriving and being added to it. That would be. That's a good idea. Huh? [00:10:12] Speaker B: That's great. [00:10:12] Speaker A: Someone should invent [00:10:13] Speaker B: some things. We have some things like that. Where. I know where my wife got it from somewhere online. And each day has, like, a bag with an item in it, and there's a card that goes with it. And it's like a prophecy from the Old Testament and the New Testament fulfillment and the item. So it's like something you open on each day of Advent, right? Like kind of like an Advent calendar in a way. But they're little bags hanging on strings in our house. And anyway, so you kind of do that and you go through. I mean, so I think you can do all the, like, you can do the fun Santa pretend stuff, but you have a. The whole month, right? You have all of Advent to focus on Christ in your home. That's probably. Hopefully that'll predominate in your house. That's. You know, no one wants Santa to predominate, but it doesn't mean he. Just because he's not doesn't mean you can't have fun with it, even if it's not the main thing. Like, our kids can handle more than one thing at a time. I think probably, maybe. [00:11:11] Speaker A: There you go. What about this? I thought you were going to bring up this Chesterton. This Chesterton quote where he says we got to have fairy tales not so that we know that there's dragons, but so that we know that the dragons can be slain. Isn't that what he says? You got that one? [00:11:26] Speaker B: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Nope. Yeah, that's exactly what he says. And again, both Lewis, Chesterton, Tolkien, all these guys understood that myth is a way of teaching you can learn real things from myth. And that's kind of how Tolkien approached Lewis, is that Christianity is the true myth. It's a true thing that happened. And you can also teach your kids about St. Nicholas. We still do the St. Nicholas Day things where you put your shoes out and they get chocolate and they get a few small items or whatever. And then we read them the story of St Nicholas and his generosity and. And little kids can handle that. The Real St. Nicholas and stories about Santa Claus, like, it's not. [00:12:08] Speaker A: This is. And we [00:12:09] Speaker B: don't have to overcomplicate. [00:12:09] Speaker A: And then the Lutheran pastors who love St Nicholas because he slapped Arius. Right? That's kind of obnoxious. He had to apologize. Allegedly. [00:12:19] Speaker B: Allegedly. Allegedly. Don't [00:12:22] Speaker A: be so happy that some guy slapped another guy, fellas. Sheesh. You should maybe just think about like, I wonder why that makes me so happy. [00:12:32] Speaker B: It's probably more important question than the Santa Claus one. All right, this is I. This one just came in recently, I guess in the last two weeks. But it's from an agnostic, so I wanted to. [00:12:43] Speaker A: Okay, [00:12:44] Speaker B: to put it up here. Does Christianity actually give hope and meaning to present? [00:12:48] Speaker A: Ah, [00:12:50] Speaker B: I want to say right away that I'm an agnostic, but I find it very interesting to listen to your Q and A. Allow me to ask a question that was. Has been occupying me lately. Christians very often say that atheists have no ultimate hope and therefore the present life is meanless. I consider this a very important question to which I have no answer. But does Christianity really give a positive answer? I mean, the Bible certainly teaches that the righteous will have eternal life and will see God himself face to face, but at the same time the present world will perish. Why doesn't this make present existence just as meaningless? Which aspects of the present life do Christians consider potentially eternal and which are purely earthly? After all, if even the closest family and marital bonds will not survive death, as Christ says, and what will remain of this present life, [00:13:33] Speaker A: that's great. So I think the way to think about meaning and purpose is that meaning is that we have. There's a continuity that, that exists between us and the past. And purpose is that there's a continuity that exists between us and the future, that that purpose is good, that the future is good. That's where hope comes from. Ephesians 2 says that before we had God, we were without hope in the world. And so this idea that, that there is something to hope in uniquely belongs to Christians, to believers in God. Let's say that, let's make it more general so that if you don't believe in God, there is no hope. And it's good for Christians to remember this, that by definition, unbelief is a form of hopelessness because everything will just eventually dissolve and decay. The explosion of the sun and then the heat death of the universe, that's the only thing that's waiting for us. But we have a future and a hope. And we. And our hope extends not only past death, which is the amazing thing. We have this hope as an anchor to the soul, that Jesus who ascended into heaven will return for us. So we have a hope in the new heaven and the new earth where the righteous dwell, but we also have hope in this life. So Paul Says, if we have hope in Christ in this life, only we're the most to be pitied. So we have hope in Christ in this life and in the life to come, so that the Lord is with us. It's the death of Jesus and the forgiveness of sins that actually gives meaning to our suffering. Otherwise, suffering has no purpose but that this life is a life of suffering in connection to the cross of Jesus. Now, this life is not meaningless. That the Lord is working all things together for those who love him and are called according to his purpose, and that there are things that will survive the judgment day. This has to do with the word of the Lord, where Isaiah says, the word of the Lord endures forever. And this is picked up by the New Testament writers. And that is to say that everything that is marked by the Lord's name endures through the fire. It's almost like the Lord, if he writes his name on something, that thing will not be destroyed. So when he writes his name on us in baptism, it's this promise, you will not be destroyed. And so we are eternal in a profound way. And even the things that we accomplish in this life, we have this promise that they will also follow us. So this great verse in Revelation that says, blessed are those who die in the Lord. They rest from their labors and their works do follow them. So that the things that are holy in this life, in other words, the things that are marked by the word of the Lord in this life, endure even into the life to come. Amazingly, [00:16:46] Speaker B: and I mean, we mentioned, like, bonds, like marital bonds. We've talked about that before. That you're not married in heaven, but doesn't mean you don't have a relationship with the people from here on earth, right? It doesn't mean you don't know them. Because I believe we'll know them as we've talked about in a more full way, right? We'll fully know them in a way that we can't know them now because they'll be, as you say, fully themselves. The full packerness, as you say, will be on display. That's [00:17:12] Speaker A: the day. That's the thing I'm waiting for. [00:17:14] Speaker B: The thing we're all waiting for. Like, it can only get better, right? Like, that's the. That's the thing. It can only get better. So we have, like, family and friends and those who are in Christ, like, we will have them with us for all eternity. Those things don't end. They'll take a different shape. They won't be exactly the same, but they'll be better in ways we can't even imagine. And so if we have that coming with us, like we do have hope for those things, we also have the hope too that, as you say, our good deeds follow us. But even right now, like the Lord uses our works in ways we can't even fathom, right? It's like he's using what we're doing in our vocations to work in the lives of others. And we don't even know how that all interconnects and how he's doing all of those things. So even now we have hope that even though I can't see it, the Lord is using my faithfulness and my vocations in spite of my sins and failings, in spite of the fact that I don't have the full packerness yet, in spite of those things, he still is using them for good, to bless others and to help others, and Lord willing to even give them hope here in this life and for the life to come. So it's not merely that we're looking, you know, hope, right? Our confession is put this way. Faith is about the present. Hope is about the future. And that I think includes part of that hope is that God, even here in this life, is using our good works to bless and help others and hopefully to give them hope for the future. Right? So faith receives God's gifts now. And hope looks to the gifts we're going to have in the future for all eternity. And we can trust Him. [00:18:44] Speaker A: I found this note. So the Christian lives with three hopes. Two great, one small. So the great hopes, Christ, our redeemer, his death and resurrection. The second great hope is Christ is the King who's returning to make all things new. But then the small hope is that tomorrow I might love and serve my neighbor a little bit better or a little more. If all we had was a small hope, then that would be despair. But when that little small hope, tomorrow I can love and serve my neighbor, is sandwiched between the death of Jesus and the return and resurrection of Jesus and the return of Jesus, then it becomes actually a wonderful hope. So that's kind of. It's great to think of it in that way. [00:19:27] Speaker B: Yeah, I think it's really helpful. All right, ready for the next one? Sure. Now, this one I thought would be good. Especially we heard a lot when we were down in Puerto Rico about the influence of the Pentecostals, especially some of the extreme form of Pentecostalism, things like that, and how it's influencing people there. So this one's on the Holy Spirit. So I thought that would be helpful. And it's something we've discussed before, but maybe not this exact part of it. So I thought it'd be helpful. Do Lutherans believe in a nudge from the Holy Spirit? Furthermore, should we even phrase it that way? I will give you a heads up. That is often the way I phrase it. So go ahead. See, if you say that's terrible, don't talk about that. [00:20:16] Speaker A: So there's a danger in this is a wonderful question. We say we confess from the Scriptures and from our confessions that the Holy Spirit only works through the Word of God to save, deliver, to forgive, etc. And anything. The Spirit working apart from the Word, we call enthusiasm. So we are delighting that the Holy Spirit has bound Himself to the Word and that that's how he works. That's how he does his work for us and in us and so forth. The danger in that is that we think that God is not involved with everything else. It's almost like we lose the doctrine of Providence or we lose how. The Lutheran fathers don't really talk about Providence, although I think they could. But they talk about how God governs the world. He governs all things. He's involved in absolutely everything. And so our doctrine of the Spirit working through the Word, it tempts us to become almost like functional atheists in that here's the Word, that's where the Lord works, and then everything else is hands off and kind of up to us. Us. That is not the biblical picture of the world. It's not the biblical picture of the Christian life. The Lord is involved in our lives top to bottom, so that when we wake up, he's with us. When we go to sleep, he's with us. Everywhere we go, he's there with us. He governs our lives. He guides our lives. He answers prayer, he gives wisdom. And the Spirit is working. So we have to rejoice that the Spirit who dwells in us is energetically dwelling in us, both to will and to do those things that are pleasing to God. Now it's not again apart from the Word, but precisely through the Word that the Spirit is present and through the Word that the Spirit works. So is the Holy Spirit? I don't know. Is the Holy Spirit directly involved in our own lives, making sure that we are willing to do according to his goodwill? The answer is yes. Now the question is, how do I discern it? Some people seem to have more spiritual sensitivity than others. But the question is maybe not. Like if I Have a thought or I have an impulse, or if I feel something that says this instead of that, if I'm leaning one way or another, do I want to credit that to the Holy Spirit or just to my own circumstances or whatever? I can test the spirits. I'm always called to test the spirits to make sure that everything is according to the Lord's word. So I can say, is this nudge in my vocation in obedience to the commandments done out of love for God and the neighbor, then praise the Lord, let's receive it as a nudge from the Holy Spirit. I think even, and I teach this, and I'm trying to do it myself, that when we worry about something, those like, gut punches where I'm like, oh, and I remember something. This is a nudge from the Holy Spirit that's reminding me to pray when I see some sort of tragedy. This is how Jesus treats, like the collapsing tower. This is a nudge from the Holy Spirit to repent. So if it's in accordance with the Lord's word and in my vocation, then we can receive it in that way. But if it's not, if it's in violation of the commandments, if it goes against my vocation, etc. Etc. Then we know that that's in fact not what's happening with the Lord's Word. [00:24:15] Speaker B: You just flipped your camera. [00:24:16] Speaker A: That's kind of cool. Looking at the back, huh? [00:24:21] Speaker B: This a live behind the scenes look at Pastor Wolfehler's [00:24:24] Speaker A: setup. That's nice. So that's how that goes, apparently. So anyway, your thoughts? [00:24:31] Speaker B: Yeah, I was thinking, the example I was thinking of, I had a few occasions, I'm sure you've had this too, as a pastor, where, like, I'll think a recent example, I woke up, like, late in the middle of the night, and all of a sudden I thought, man, I really need to pray for this specific person. And so I prayed for them. And then you wake up and check in on them and they're like, yeah, man, I really going through this, this thing or that thing, right? Like, I, I don't, I don't think Christians should write that off as like a coincidence, right? Or just like, I got lucky that I happened to pray for them and they actually did need prayer about something serious, you know, Like, I think I can chalk that up to, hey, the Holy Spirit actually works and wanted me to pray for that person in that moment. So I think that's something that we have to consider. So those are the kind of things where I think, right, You Pray for someone and you weren't thinking about them, and you thought about them, you prayed for them. And now you check in on them and they're like, yeah, I really needed prayer today because this thing's going on. The idea that we could just say that they can't be the Holy Spirit, that's just like random luck or chance or whatever. Like, that seems entirely atheistic. Like you were saying. Like, it's kind of an atheistic worldview. Like, God can't have. Couldn't have possibly had me pray for this person or reach out to this person. Like, it had to have been just from myself. It just seems a little. Seems a little silly to view it that way. [00:25:57] Speaker A: It does. So the danger is that then we start looking for all those things, and we want the Holy Spirit to communicate through all of these little impulses. And we make ourselves like little Christian magicians where there's a hidden will of God and now we have to go and kind of discern it. So we can receive all of these things as gifts from the Holy Spirit as long as they line up with the Lord's word. If they don't, then we throw them out and we don't put them on anybody else. That's a really important thing. If the Holy Spirit brings something to me, wisdom or comfort or whatever, that's for me. If the Holy Spirit wants something to belong to the entire church, that belongs to the Scripture. So I definitely do not start to put whatever is given to me onto everybody else. The private stuff stays private and the public, that belongs to us and to the whole church. So that's another really important distinction. And remember this discernment, it kind of takes three ways. So one, whatever nudge lines up with the scripture, then, praise God, I have the Scripture. So that nudged me to the scripture. Number two, the nudge contradicts the scripture, then it's obviously the demons or my own sinful flesh. If the nudge is beyond, it neither contradicts nor is in line with the Scriptures, but it's just something neutral. Then it comes to us as a suggestion. Suggestion. Because I'm bound to the scriptures, I'm not bound to my nudges. So that we. There's a way that this. When the Scriptures are governing and ruling and reigning, they stand above all these things. And that's. That's really important for us to. To rejoice in and think about. [00:27:40] Speaker B: All right, the next one's on healing oneself. [00:27:44] Speaker A: Look at how your face already sort of cringes. I'm ready healing Oneself. All right, [00:27:52] Speaker B: physician, heal thyself. So I see a functional medicine doctor and also have a primary care physician. [00:27:58] Speaker A: Ah, so [00:27:58] Speaker B: one is. One is holistic and one is regular medicine. [00:28:01] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:28:01] Speaker B: I listen to various holistic podcasts that talk about our bodies being able to heal themselves. [00:28:06] Speaker A: Okay. [00:28:06] Speaker B: And this makes me feel like it's going too far. Like we think we are making ourselves as idols. I still agree with the functional medicine premise of looking for underlying causes of illness before just prescribing drugs, but rather looking at the deeper blood work and lifestyle issues that might be affecting health. But it seems to go too far to just keep saying that our bodies are made to and can heal themselves. And that seems wrong to some extent. [00:28:31] Speaker A: Well, [00:28:32] Speaker B: what and where in the. They have one more question. Oh, [00:28:34] Speaker A: yeah, okay. [00:28:34] Speaker B: What and where. I [00:28:35] Speaker A: was got excited. I was ready to go. I'm jumping in on this. [00:28:38] Speaker B: Ready to go. What and where in the Bible would I look for. For clarity on this? [00:28:42] Speaker A: So look at there. There is like. So in some ways, obviously the Bible can heal itself, right? Like you get a cut and it somehow fixes itself. Like you get a scab and the skill. The skin heals and it go. And you get sick and your body hasn't. I mean, we have our whole immune system which addresses this. This problem is that we. All this stuff is trying to kill us and our body is fighting it off all the time. And so you get sick and then you get better. And. And there's certain, of course, medicines and things that we do that can strengthen that immune system, that can help and aid the healing, but that is able to. That it's a sort of autocorrecting system is one of the most amazing things, I think, as evidence of how God has created us, how we're fearfully and wonderfully made. It's an amazing thing. And it's not just connected to physical stuff. That there's a connection between the soul and the body that is profound. So. So King David says, when I kept silenced, my bones waxed old for groaning all the day long. In other words, my lack of repentance actually was injuring my body. I think that's pretty amazing. How the conscience, how a free, clean conscience actually affects the health of the body is something to really consider. And, you know, I mean, we know it too. When we're bent over with sadness or guilt or shame, it creates a weariness there. And when we have. There's a reason that the clean conscience is described like the calves leaping from the stall. There's actually a kind of There's a joyful energy to having a good clean conscience. So that there's a connection between all these different things, especially when we think about mental health, that there' swe don't want to say, well, there's nothing chemical about it because we know there's something chemical about it. I mean, you drink too much beer and it affects your mind. It's like that's a chemical reaction that affects your mental health and that when you don't eat, you get hangry and it affects your mood. Like of course this is all related. We are much more complicated than, than I think will maybe even ever know. It's pretty amazing like how the, how the non physical thing of the soul can actually give you thoughts and words and move. I mean it's just like, it's marvelous. It's marvelous. And the doctors are trying to figure that out. Although, you know, they. Nobody knows what they're doing. It's great. It's. It's really, I mean it's wonderful. So I think it's fine to think about how the body does have this immune system that's fighting itself off and it's also spiritually connected. It can get really kooky real quick. So when you get into this kind of positive thinking and projection and all that kind of Joel Osteen, New age scientist. New age science, not scientists, but like, like what's the L. Ron Hubbard thing that I'm trying to think of? [00:32:07] Speaker B: Scientology. [00:32:07] Speaker A: Scientology. I mean, but even just the positive, whole positive thinking movement when, when you start. I mean I. There's something about, like when you hear people talking about neuroplasticity and in some ways there's some real wonderful biblical thoughts about that. Like as we pray, so we are who we worship, shapes the very shape of our humanity and so forth. But then there's some, also some pretty kooky things that can come in there pretty quick. So you just got to be careful with some discernment. But I think there's a, the whole, I mean like this amazing gift that the Lord has given us in our body ought to make us daily so thankful. [00:32:53] Speaker B: I was thinking a little bit different angle from this too. I agree with what you were saying because I mean it's, it's obvious, like right. If you eat better, you feel better. Like there's all these kind of things you can in many ways, like heal yourself. Your body can heal itself in those ways, but with some of this holistic stuff. One things I've seen sometimes some of those holistic stuff pits like all medicine is bad. You don't need any medicine. You just need to like, you know, eat, eat some plants and you'll be fine or whatever. Like. But then I think it even sometimes it goes beyond that. I've, I've seen these things, I'm sure you've seen this too, where it becomes sometimes full on, sometimes adjacent to witchcraft. Like, like we know some herbs and some, some things out in nature, like have benefits. Like, we know that and that's all well proven. And we can say, yeah, this thing can actually help you. But then there's this whole other category that I see come up all the time when it comes to this discussion, which is mix these things and do this stuff. And it's almost like you're like, I've even seen, I've even seen Christian share stuff like, and sit it under the moon for so many days. And I'm like, [00:33:56] Speaker A: what? [00:33:57] Speaker B: That's, that's like full on, just like witchcraft. You're just, you're literally doing witchcrafter or mix these things and it will, you know, it'll, it'll help your friendships or whatever. Like you're getting, you're moving in from like holistic healing to. And some of these things looking at underlying causes which I think all that's fine. I think it was actually the Theopolis Institute that had some great articles on healthcare and some of these issues that I thought were really fantastic. But then it moves into some really weird stuff where it borders to me just like on. You're basically trying to do witchcraft at this point. Now I mix these things and get a potion and put it under the moon or do it the right way. And then now not only is my body healing, but my friendships are healing and my spirit is whatever. Like all this stuff, it's just. And I see Christians talking about it and sharing it and I'm like, wow, where do you think that's okay? Like, how did you get to that point? And if you probably looked into where you got it from, it's probably sometimes literal witches that you're getting it from. So all that to say, like, stay in the real scientific, like medical side of it, whether it's holistic or your actual doc, your regular physician, and be careful of getting into the weird stuff like this. I [00:35:14] Speaker A: just, I cannot stop thinking about the health conscious cholos. There's nothing essential about this oil essay. Do you know that? [00:35:24] Speaker B: I do not. [00:35:25] Speaker A: Do they have an essential oil for stupid. They actually do. Oh boy. We gotta, we'll need a link to that in the description health conscious cholos. Oh, [00:35:40] Speaker B: that's related to our next one, though. Since. Since. Since you brought that in. [00:35:44] Speaker A: Now we're gonna get all the essential oil hate. Oh, boy. [00:35:48] Speaker B: What should Christian [00:35:49] Speaker A: Claus hate? Essential oil. That's the next one. [00:35:54] Speaker B: Yeah. So it ties in nicely. What's your Christian humor be like? What is the proper place of humor in the Christian life? What does Ephesians 5, 4 mean when it talks about crude joking or Matthew 12:36 when it talks about idle words? What kinds of dangerous temptations should we be aware of when making jokes? Oh, [00:36:10] Speaker A: that's great. [00:36:10] Speaker B: Surely God has a sense of humor since he created the platypus. [00:36:14] Speaker A: That's the proof of it. The platypus. Poor platypus. [00:36:17] Speaker B: That's [00:36:19] Speaker A: hating on platypus. Now we're going to get all the platypus people. Hey, I didn't say it. That came from a question. We don't approve of all the opinions. [00:36:27] Speaker B: Shots fired at platypus. [00:36:28] Speaker A: Biological opinions of our listeners. Platypus haters. I wrote a little essay on preaching with humor from Luther, and I went through all. Because I read through all of Luther's sermons on the house apostle. I marked all the quips and jokes that he made in there, and I would be reading them and laughing and laughing, and I'd take it into Carrie and she'd be like, that's not that funny. But we have it in the Scriptures. I mean, even the Scriptures itself, there's these play on words, there's these humorous things. Jesus is funny. I mean, you know, when he says stuff like that, you know, the camel has to go through the eye of a needle, or you strain the gnat and drink the camel. I mean, or you. You try to get the speck out of your neighbor's eye while you have a plank in your own eye. Or I mean, just this. All this stuff is. There's some. There's some humor, there's some irony in it, and it's wonderful to see. And the prophets are full of all of this rhetorical humor. And so it's not. And we're made that way. And I think it's great. CS Lewis has some warnings about this, because the problem with humor and this is. And boy, every pastor, every person who stands up to talk knows this pressure is that you. You see something that would be funny, but it just would be. It wouldn't be helpful. But humor becomes an excuse for breaking the commandments, for saying things that you ought not to say. So that when it becomes. When it ceases to be edifying, when it becomes coarse, and that coarseness could be just in the language itself or in the thing that's being talked about, then it becomes completely unchristian, and we have to avoid that altogether. And so that's the call is how can we be joyful in this way and even ironic or sarcastic or whatever sort of rhetorical device that's humorous, but do it in a way that's godly and not violating the commandments? [00:38:45] Speaker B: It seems like if you just look out there, there's a lot of really great comedians we're talking about on this trip. We talked about Nate Bargazzi, for example, who's got a lot of really clean comedy. Kevin James, there's, you know, there's Jim Gaffigan and there's a whole host of others. What is that, a website or page? Dry bar comedy, I think, where, like, all of their other comedians are, like, super clean and don't. Aren't using it to just rip others apart or to, you know, just make everything some kind of sexual innuendo or whatever it is. Like, they're. They're actually. There's being funny. Right. And so there's definitely a place for that in the life of the Christian. And like you said, the way we should really view that is, like, the Commandments are the fence, and inside that fence, there's a lot of room for comedy to play and have fun. And there's all kinds of things you can do with that. And if you're within that fence, then go for it and enjoy it. But once you start getting outside that fence and you start using comedy to just, like, rip apart others. Right. And to violate the Eighth Commandment, for example, or just using comedy merely to violate the Six Commandments or whatever it may be, like you've just got. Then we have a problem and we need to reevaluate. But humor should be, I think. I think, should be a central part of the Christian life. Honestly, like, God created us to enjoy humor and to laugh and to have fun and to. To honestly, to be happy. And so we talked about Chesterton, one of the previous answers, but. Right. Chesterton talks about the problem with most people. The reason they can't laugh or have fun is because they. They take themselves too seriously. Right. And so most people who don't have a sense of humor, it's, It's. It's not even that they. They take life too seriously or whatever. It's themselves, like, they can't laugh because it's a Wrong view of self and usually probably pride in there is a big part of it. But most Christians should be able to laugh and joke without any issues and have fun and play within the fence of the Ten Commandments and have at it. Like, we've got our friend, right, Hans Finnegan, who has a whole channel Lutheran satire that makes funny things. And it's great. We need more of that. I think we need more Christians thinking about comedy and how to use their gifts to make people laugh. [00:41:13] Speaker A: Do you know, I. This is a funny thing. So I, at some point did a standup routine some years ago at the Brothers of John the Stanford. I [00:41:23] Speaker B: remember [00:41:23] Speaker A: that. This is bad, though. So I tell a joke, and the joke is actually about people mishearing what you say. And it sounds like. I listened to the video and because a couple of people complained, it sounds like I dropped the F bomb in the middle of this joke. And I don't. But it sounds like it. I got pretty. I got pretty close. But it's this great irony that I'm telling a joke about how people don't hear what you say rightly. And the recording sounds like. So there was people who. They were like, we almost didn't come to your church because we thought, what kind of pastor drops the F bomb on a YouTube video? And I don't use that language. I mean, just even privately or. I mean, I try to be careful about this whole thing, to speak in a way that's edifying and not violating the Lord's word. So never would. I mean, I can't say never, but this is not who I am. But they almost didn't come to church. And I can't get the guys to go and take the video down or edit it to where it would sound right. But this is part of the danger in comedy is that it actually serves a purpose in culture because we give leeway to people who are making jokes. So if someone's joking about something, you give them more space. So the comedians are kind of the. It's like they get. It's like the court jester can make fun of the king. The comedians are exempt from the blasphemy laws that exist in every culture. And they have to do that to kind of tear down the idols of the culture. So. So we give this leeway to comedy. We have to be careful that we don't use that to sin, that we don't use the freedom that exists in comedy as a. As an excuse to cover vice. So that's the. You know, that's the Thing that we have to be very careful of. [00:43:25] Speaker B: And I think we have to. We don't want to go like, they're so called, like, dark humor, right? And I saw this, this great thing with several comedians, all secular comedians. I don't even think any of them are Christians, but they were talking about the situation where someone's relatives died. It was really tragic. But the way they handled it was it ended up becoming like a running. Like a running joke among them about they had several deaths in the family back to back, and it became a running joke with them about the deaths. And it wasn't that they were treating death lightly or weren't taking it seriously. It's just that they were using like a darker humor to get through it, right? To process it and to help. So, I mean, there's a lot of people you'll see that work in, like, really jobs are very heavy, right? Like, whether it's police officers or firefighters or whatever, or even pastors, times, like, there's really heavy things you deal with. And you see. And sometimes the way they deal with that is joking about it, and they're not doing it in a way to like, violate the commandments or whatever, but it's just a way of processing. And I think sometimes we forget that there's. There's a place even for that. But again, there. There are times where you're going to fall, you're going to cross those lines when you're doing stuff like that, and you have to know who you're talking to and what they're dealing with. Like, that's. If you don't know them well, it's probably a bad place to start, right? It's like making light of something very serious. But if you're really good friends, that might be what they need. And you know, that's what they need to make a joke about it. And that could be the thing that gives them a smile in them. It's a really dark situation. And so know, knowing people, knowing the situation, it may be appropriate. In other cases, it may be entirely inappropriate and you shouldn't do it. So [00:45:07] Speaker A: what about joking in preaching? [00:45:11] Speaker B: I think the danger is, I think for us, I think there can be an absolute place for it. I think that the hard part is sometimes the people can't tell you're telling a joke, right? Or that it's like, meant to be sarcastic or funny. Like, you just have to be really careful with it because, like, you, like you experienced, they mishear it and then. Or they don't get the joke and the worst thing isn't that they don't laugh like that. That happens all the time to pastors. The worst thing is that they mishear it and it leads them to like a false conclusion about something because they didn't, they didn't get that you were joking about something. So I think there's. Because I think we see this in the Bible too. I think there's a place for, there can be an absolute place for that. And then the other danger I think is the pastor wanting to be a stand up comedian, wanting to just get the laughs. And that's a danger. But one of the things comedy can do in preaching is, right, if you get someone laughing, you've kind of gotten through their defenses and that can allow other things you have to say that are more serious to get through, right? So you get them smiling and laughing with you, and then all of a sudden now you have something really heavy to bring in. Maybe it's the law or maybe it's the gospel or whatever, but you have something much more serious and heavy. But they've lowered their defenses because you've got them laughing. So I think it can be used, but it has to be used. Well, I think it should be used sparingly. Like I don't think a sermon should be like 15 minutes of one liners or whatever. [00:46:38] Speaker A: I found this essay that I wrote about Luther's humor and preaching. And so here's a warning first from Luther. He says if we were to relate to the people some idle tales and stories, they would remember them at once. Whereas now thousands upon thousands hear repeatedly the preaching of the gospel without retaining it and without profit by its instruction. They come back from church just as they went there. They hear the word but disregard it as something common and unimportant. So like the idle funny stories you can remember easily, but it's hard to remember the gospel. But anyway, [00:47:11] Speaker B: I mean, that's a danger I remember looking into. People want to do these things with kids, right, where they bring out an object and do an object lesson with kids, and sometimes people do it with adults too. And what happens is there's lots of studies on this. People remember the object and not the, not the lesson. So if you have a great joke and it's so good that it has them laughing, but it could be so good that that's all that they remember is the joke and not anything else. So it has to be supporting what you're doing or like I said, being used to get them to open up to what you have to say. Next. But we have to be careful with it. And I think it's easier to do that in Bible study than in a sermon. Right. Because it's a little more relaxed environment. It's a little different. I think it's easier to use some jokes in Bible study than it is in sermons. [00:48:01] Speaker A: I think that there's the playfulness. And this comes back to the very first thing we were talking about about Santa Claus. There's a playfulness to the cheerful heart. And you can tell when someone is sad and they just don't want it. They're just that melancholy heart. But when the Lord is. When he's giving that joyfulness, it kind of. There's a. Again, just a silliness that's there. A playfulness that's there. That's. That's. That's good. [00:48:33] Speaker B: Yeah, absolutely. [00:48:34] Speaker A: Yeah. [00:48:36] Speaker B: That's it. That's five. [00:48:37] Speaker A: That is. Well, thank you YouTube theologians for your questions. Wolfmila Co slash what I forgot comment contact. That's what it is. And you can send some more agnostics. You guys get to front of the line. I guess I better. Atheist questions will go poom. Straight to the top. So there you go. Someone's going to say I'm an atheist and I'm wondering how I should lead my family prayers or whatever. I'm an atheist. Could you help me understand the two natures? [00:49:07] Speaker B: Can you explain the genus Myostaticum to me? [00:49:09] Speaker A: Wolfhero co Wednesday for the free weekly newsletter. Wednesday whatnot. Keep an eye out for that. It's great. And thanks. Pastor Packer, welcome back. I hope that tattoo of yours heals soon. [00:49:23] Speaker B: Hopefully be back at it [00:49:25] Speaker A: long sleeve clericals. Till then. Thanks for being here. God's peace be with you. See that?

Other Episodes